Pros
  • able to promote collaborative work with artists, musicians, actors, e.g., in weekly seminar
  • promote collaborative culture
  • common needs in common space
  • create momentum for changes
  • create regional identity for arts community
  • formation of college gives admin voice: dean that speaks only to arts vs. CAS
  • CAS dean doesn’t have to deal with arts but can focus on other areas more
  • majors could get advising from faculty outside CAS to bolster liberal arts element
  • collectively, sizeable entity that could have larger impact on community
  • stronger voice with the legislature collectively rather than as individual units or as part of CAS
  • easier to support fundraising staff in each unit (couldn’t dedicate staff within CAS as easily)

 

Cons
  • could promote college work within existing structure
  • different languages among different disciplines
  • arts historians may lose humanities role within CAS; may feel uncomfortable within COA
  • contributes to "silo" effect of isolation across faculty
  • will art history appear within CAS anywhere?
  • lose an element of liberal arts within CAS
  • majors may lose sight of importance of liberal arts in their education
  • identity takes long time to create and disseminate, which could hinder fundraising efforts for entire COA
  • increased staff (dean, assoc dean) and other new resources needed for admin levels (that’s equal to 2-3 faculty lines)
  • lose discretionary funds/IDC that might trickle down from other depts. within CAS but that might not be there with smaller unit
  • lots of work for nothing?
  • additional work (creating admin structure, policies and procedures) without additional resources